The rugby world is reeling! Scott Robertson's sudden departure as All Blacks head coach has ignited a firestorm of debate, and fans are already clamoring for his replacement. It's a move that's left many scratching their heads, wondering why a coach with a solid 74% win rate was shown the door just two years into his contract. But here's where it gets controversial... who should take the reins?
New Zealand Rugby's decision to part ways with Robertson, despite his winning record (20 wins out of 27 Tests), has sent shockwaves through the sport. To put that win rate into perspective, it places him seventh among All Blacks coaches who have led the team in at least 20 Tests. While impressive, it's worth noting the company he keeps:
- 87% – Steve Hansen (W93 D4 L10)
- 86% – Alex Wyllie (W25 D1 L3)
- 85% – Graham Henry (W88 L15)
- 82% – John Mitchell (W23 D1 L4)
- 80% – Neil McPhail (W16 D2 L2)
- 76% – John Hart (W31 D1 L9)
- 74% – Scott Robertson (W20 L7)
- 70% – Ian Foster (W32 D2 L12)
- 68% – Laurie Mains (W23 D1 L10)
Following the announcement of Robertson's exit, Planet Rugby asked fans to weigh in on who they'd like to see take over in 2026. We presented a shortlist of 15 potential candidates, ranging from seasoned veterans to rising stars. While several coaches garnered support, two names emerged as clear favorites: Jamie Joseph and Joe Schmidt. And this is the part most people miss... the contrasting styles and experiences each candidate brings to the table.
Jamie Joseph, currently preparing the Highlanders for the Super Rugby Pacific season, has been a contender for the All Blacks head coaching role in the past, having been pipped to the post by Ian Foster and then Robertson. His experience leading Japan to unprecedented success at the 2019 Rugby World Cup makes him a compelling choice. He knows how to build a team culture and get the best out of his players. Some might say his dedication to the Highlanders shows he's committed elsewhere, but the allure of the All Blacks job is undeniable.
On the other hand, Joe Schmidt, currently contracted with Rugby Australia until July, is a name synonymous with tactical brilliance and meticulous preparation. His impact as an assistant coach in the lead-up to the 2023 Rugby World Cup was undeniable, injecting fresh ideas and tightening up the All Blacks' game. The 60-year-old is highly respected both within the squad and globally. The big question is: should NZ Rugby try to lure him back despite his current commitments? Is his tactical genius worth the potential complications?
As of now, Joseph holds a narrow lead in our fan poll, but the race is far from over. It's a testament to the passion and knowledge of All Blacks supporters that the debate is so intense. But here's a thought... is the 'fan favorite' always the right choice? Does popularity equate to the best strategic fit for the team? What about coaches who might not have the same public profile but possess the skills and vision to take the All Blacks to new heights?
Ultimately, the decision rests with New Zealand Rugby, but the fans' voices are being heard loud and clear. Who do you think should be the next All Blacks head coach, and why? Do you agree with the current poll results, or do you believe another candidate deserves the opportunity to lead the team? Let us know your thoughts in the comments below! And one more question: Is it right to sack a coach that has a 74% win rate? Perhaps it's time to re-evaluate how win rates are used to measure success?
